It’s Just a Copy, Right? “or” Who Owns My Culture?
Monday, October 27th, 2008I’ve been thinking a bit about Copyright and Intellectual Property lately. I’ve been thinking about it because I am a creator, and because I think a lot about the creative process. And, because I read The Chronicles of Narnia every so often.
Hmm?
Let me explain. You may remember the scene from The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe where Santa Claus shows up, seemingly out of place in the Lewis universe. But, if you read the books, you will see such cross-overs happening quite often. Prince Caspian (the book) features Baccus and other Greek mythology characters. In fact, they play a major role in the story. One of Lewis’ points in the book is to show how God’s truth and beauty shows up across the world’s mythology (and how it can also redeem it). It’s a point that is made more powerful when that mythology actually shows up in Lewis’ story - in recognizable form.
As I read through this, I got to thinking …what if I want to do something similar today? What if I want to include, in my story, the characters of another story? And who are the characters my culture holds dear? What are our common mythologies? Star Wars? Buzz and Woody? Neo? What if I decided to have any of these characters walk into my work?
I’d be breaking the law, I imagine. Those characters and mythologies, unlike Baccus, are owned and regulated. They make up my culture, but they don’t belong to me.
Or to you.
So, I am wondering what this means to us? The fact that modern copyright laws will push work we can reference and incorporate and re-create back farther and farther into the past and irrelevance is frustrating to me.
Creativity should sustain and author. But it should never be a cash cow milked to all eternity. After all, once you create one Mickey, you can coast then, right? Why create something else at all?
Anyways, just some thoughts I am thinking. I think this is a major cultural shift (there are no fireside stories any more and no folk-songs we all own and share). We now lived in a borrowed (or paid-for) culture. What mark will that fact make on our own cultural contributions? How is our ability to create affected?
This post was again sparked by listening to Search Engine with Jessie Brown, on CBC. You can read a relevant post, and watch a trailer for a documentary about just this issue, here…
http://www.cbc.ca/searchengine/blog/2008/10/rip_a_remix_manifesto.html#more
Tell me what you think about all of this? Is there value in the “cultural remix”? Should we be free to rework common mythologies and explore the values of those pre-created worlds? Is that a slippery slope?






